Commodities and Items on the WoW Forever Auction House
The World of Warcraft: Forever auction house sells two kinds of thing in two different ways. Commodities are stackable goods such as cloth, ore, herbs and dust: every seller's stock is pooled and buyers take as many as they want from the cheapest first. Items are everything else, such as armour, weapons, recipes and bags: each one is its own auction, with a bid and a buyout. Knowing which you are selling changes how you should price it.
The short version
| Commodities | Items | |
|---|---|---|
| What they are | Stackable goods: cloth, ore, bars, herbs, dust, food | Gear, weapons, recipes, bags, anything not stackable |
| How they are listed | One pooled price list per item | One auction each |
| How buyers buy | Any quantity, cheapest units first | The whole auction |
| Bids | No, a unit price only | Yes, bid or buyout |
| Can sell in part | Yes | No |
| Who sells first | The lowest unit price | Whichever auction the buyer picks |
On the EU PvP Horde house on 16 November 2026, our snapshot held 158,778 commodity listings covering 1,312 different goods and 2.6 million units, and 166,803 item auctions covering 5,321 different items. Commodities are about a fifth of the different goods and nearly all of the units for sale.
How commodities sell
When you post a stack of a commodity you choose a quantity and a price per unit. Your stock joins everyone else's in one list, sorted by unit price. A buyer types how many they want and the game takes them from the cheapest listings upward. Three things follow from that.
The cheapest unit always sells first. There is no way for a buyer to pick your listing over a cheaper one, so being a copper under the next seller puts you at the front of the queue, and being a copper over puts you behind all of their stock.
Your listing can sell in parts. We have seen this in our own records: one posting of 193 Strange Dust sold as two separate sales, 130 units and then 63 units, under the same auction id. Each part arrived as its own mail.
The deposit comes back in proportion. On that same posting the 1 silver deposit was returned as 67 copper with the first part and 32 copper with the second. If the rest of a commodity listing expires, only the unsold share of the deposit is lost.
How items sell
Each item is a separate auction with a starting bid and, usually, a buyout price. A buyer sees every auction and chooses one, so the cheapest does not automatically go first: a slightly dearer auction with a shorter time left, or a suffix the buyer wants, can sell ahead of yours. Items with random suffixes such as "of the Eagle" are priced separately, which is why an item page on wowfah shows a table of variants.
Because every item is its own auction, an item either sells whole or does not sell, and the deposit comes back whole or is lost whole.
What this means for pricing
- Commodities: look at depth, not the cheapest listing. One player dumping twenty units at a silly price moves the cheapest listing but not the market. The item page's cheapest listings table shows how many units sit at each price, and the market price is the average of the cheapest 15% of units. Price to be in front of the big walls of stock, not the stray cheap one.
- Commodities: undercutting by one copper is enough. The queue is strictly by price. Cutting deeper only gives gold away.
- Items: check what actually sells. For gear and recipes, the sold in 24 hours figure matters more than the cheapest buyout. Many item auctions sit unsold for days.
- Both: mind the deposit on things that do not sell. A deposit is a cost of failing to sell. See cut and deposit explained.
To see the difference for yourself, open today's WoW Forever auction house prices, pick your house, and compare a commodity such as Linen Cloth with any green weapon.
FAQ
What is a commodity on the WoW Forever auction house?
A stackable trade good such as cloth, ore, bars, herbs, leather or enchanting dust. All sellers' stock of a commodity is pooled into one price list, and buyers take units from the cheapest upward.
Can part of my auction sell?
Yes, for commodities. A buyer can take any number of units, so a stack can sell in several parts to different buyers. Single items always sell whole.
Do commodities have bids?
No. Commodities have a unit price only. Bids exist on item auctions, where each auction has a starting bid and usually a buyout.
Why did my cheap listing not sell first?
For a commodity, the cheapest unit price always sells first, so check that nobody is listed below you. For an item, buyers choose the auction they want, so a cheaper price does not guarantee the sale.
Do I lose my whole deposit if only some of a stack sells?
No. In the sales we have recorded, the deposit was returned in proportion to what sold. Only the unsold share is lost if the rest expires.
Sources and method
The listing counts are from wowfah's snapshot of the EU PvP Horde auction house on 16 November 2026, taken from the auction data Blizzard publishes for World of Warcraft: Forever. The part sale and deposit figures are from real sales recorded with the wowfah Ledger addon on the same day. The difference between pooled commodity listings and single item auctions is visible in Blizzard's data itself: commodity listings carry a unit price and quantity only, and item auctions carry a bid and a buyout. How the numbers work.